Class Research Resources and Assignments

Week 3
Lecture for Week 3
Slides for Week 3 Lecture
Link to Supplementary Material for Week 2

The Social Context of Scientific Knowledge
 
The History of Climate Science Since the 1950s -
Knowledge, Belief and Behavior

Readings:
Spencer Weart
 
The Discovery of Global Warming (Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 2003), Capters 4-6, pp. 66-141.
 
In addition to the text in the book itself, please continue to explore the relevant online support material located at the American Institute of Physic's website. Note that you may download the full support material in HTML format or in PDF format, or you may oder the material on a CD.
 


plus, three articles:

Timothy C. Weiskel
 
1989

'"While Angels Weep..." Doing Theology on A Small Planet.' The Harvard Divinity Bulletin, XIX, 3 (1989).

 
Timothy C. Weiskel
 
1990

"The Need for Miracles in the Age of Science," The Harvard Divinity Bulletin, XX, 2, (Summer 1990).

     
Timothy C. Weiskel
 
2005

“From Sidekick to Sideshow — Celebrity, Entertainment, and the Politics of Distraction: Why Americans Are ‘Sleepwalking Toward the End of the Earth,’” American Behavioral Scientist, 49, 3, (November 2005), pp. 393-409.

 

Supplementary Material

Graphic Representations of Key Paleoclimate Data:

 

Supplementary Material

 

Bedtime Story: Trial of the Century: Co-Conspirators Convicted, 24 January 2005.

James Hansen* and Makiko Sato, Greenhouse gas growth rates, PNAS,November 16, 2004, vol. 101, no. 46, 16109–16114.


Supplementary Material
on
Knowledge, Belief and Behavior
Consider the differing "worldviews" and belief systems reflected
in the following material. How do these belief systems
shape our "knowledge system?"

ABC Evening News
  "A Closer Look (Global Warming)," ABC Evening News, (8 February 2006, Wednesday)..
CNN News
  "Silenced on global warning?," CNN News Online, (16 February 2006).
Nigel Hawkes
   "Waterworld: how life on Earth will look 1,000 years from now," The Times Online, (17 February 2006).
Christine McGourty
  "Greenland's glaciers melting fast," BBC News Online, (16 February 2006).
Alister Doyle
  "A year on, Kyoto climate backers urge US action," Reuters, (16 February 2006 12:54 GMT, Thursday).
Democracy Now
  "Is Sci-Fi Writer Michael Chricton Advising Bush on Global Warming?" Democracy Now, (21 February 2006).


Consider the "worldvview" of some key players in the corporate world:

Peter Robinson - [What can we learn about "the culture" of the oil business?]

 

"The Interview," BBC - The Interview, (16 February 2006).

This week on The Interview, Mike Williams meets Peter Robertson -- a man who sits at the top table in one of the most wealthy and powerful industries.

As vice-chairman of the American oil giant Chevron, he deals with projects from Angola to Australia and last year oversaw profits of more than 14 billion dollars.

But his company is facing up to the end of its life-blood. When the world's finite oil reserves eventually run out, Chevron is starting to ask what comes next. So does Peter Robertson have any answers?

BBC News Online
  "Nigeria oil 'total war' warning," BBC News Online, (17 February 2006, 16:05 GMT Friday).

 

Compare Peter Robertson's "worldview" with that of Lee Raymond, Chair of Exxon MobilCorp, expressed almost two years ago...
What can we say about the content and the structure of their respective belief systems?
How do these belief systems differ from the knowledge system of the scientific community?

Exxon Mobil's Lee Raymond - Interview with Charlie Rose, 6 May 2004

 

Lee Raymond, chief executive officer of Exxon MobilCorp., talks with Charlie Rose in New York about worldwide dependency on oil from the Middle East, the effects of rising oil prices and his position of the threat of global warming on the environment.

[Lee Raymond retired from Exxon MobilCorp in August of 2005. What about his "worldview"? did this disappear from the corporation when he stepped down?]


Compare both Peter Robertson's and Lee Raymond's "worldviews"
with other "energy experts"

Daniel Yergin and Lord Oxburgh

 

Fuelling the Future, BBC World Service, Have Your Say, (Sunday,19 February 2006)

What are all the experts assuming collectively?
What are they failing to see collectively?

Is the "energy crisis" the same thing as the "climate crisis?"
Or does it serve as a major distraction from what we
should devote our attention to most closely?



** Return to Syllabus **