Class Research Resources and Assignments

Week 13
Supplementary Material for Week 12 - Abrupt Climate Change
Lectures for Week 13

Technological Options and Government Policy

Part I. Are Techincal "Fixes" Possible? What do they Cost? Thinking About Low Energy Building
(and Who Makes Government Policy?)

and

Part II. Argument, Advocacy, Fiction and Reality: Locating Truth in the Age of Perpetual Spin - Slides

 

Reading:

Stephen H. Schneider (Editor), John O. Niles (Editor), Armin Rosencranz (Editor)
2002
Climate Change Policy: A Survey (Washington, D. C., Island Press, 2002), pp. 115-218, 307-371, 411-522.
Timothy C. Weiskel
2005
“From Sidekick to Sideshow—Celebrity, Entertainment, and the Politics of Distraction Why Americans Are ‘Sleepwalking Toward the End of the Earth,’” American Behavioral Scientist, 49, 3, (November 2005), pp. 393-409.

Supplementary Materials

 


For assessments of technical mitigation strategies you should consult the publications of "Working Group III" of the IPCC, particularly Chapter 3. See:

Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
2001
"Technological and Economic Potential of Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reduction," Chapter 3 in, Climate Change 2001: Working Group III: Mitigation (Geneva, IPCC, 2001).


What about technical possibilities for alternative energy?

 

 

 

Bruce Lambert
2004
"Agency Plans to Harvest Wind Power Off Jones Beach," The New York Times, (2 May 2004).
BBC News Online
2004
"One Planet - Alternate Fuels," BBC News Online, (15 April 2004).
 

Are environmentalists afraid to tackle alternative energy? This week One Planet looks at the fast growing sector of offshore energy generation. Increasingly wind farms are being sited at sea, whilst wave and tidal power are finally taking off, after years of technical and financial problems.

But very little is known about the potential environmental consequences of these new infrastructures. For green campaigners it is hard to complain about these supposedly clean alternatives to fossil fuels.

One of the problems with alternate energy systems is how to relate them to the existing energy "grid." There are many technical components to this problem, but some cultures are attempting to address them because they regard the goal of integration as an important one. See, for example:

Tyndall Centre
2004
Integrating Renewables and CHP into the UK Electricity System - Tyndall Centre Technical Report No. 13, Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research, (March 2004).
   
BBC News Online
2004
"The Climate Group," Newshour, April 27, 2004.
 

 

Techniques for Carbon Sequestration:

Alex Kirby
2004
"World 'must have carbon stores'," BBC News Online, (29 April, 2004, 10:14 GMT 11:14 UK Thursday).
 

The cuts the world will have to make in emissions of carbon dioxide are so huge it will have to find other ways to deal with the gas, a British scientist says.
He is Professor John Shepherd of the UK's Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research, a leading scientific group.

Professor Shepherd says this will mean studying ways to store carbon and alter the Earth's albedo (its reflectivity).

He also believes nuclear power may be needed to fill the gap until cleaner sources can replace most fossil fuels.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Are We Addicted To Oil? - Series - WBUR The Connection
 
  "Addicted to Oil: Part One," NPR - WBUR - The Connection, (25 April 2005).
      The price of gas will top the agenda when President Bush sits down today with Saudi Crown Prince Abdullah. President Bush is hoping if the Saudis increase production, prices at American pumps will fall. Right now, drivers are paying about $2.30 a gallon and there's no end in sight as the summer travel season approaches.
    The New York Times columnist Tom Friedman says the problem with gas prices is not that they are too high -- but that they are too low. Set them at $4.00 a gallon and then you will see Detroit changing its ways he says.
    It's not just the price of gas; but the future of democracy in Arab countries, and the economic fortunes of people here, Friedman says, that hinge on whether this country decides to get serious about conservation.
 
  "Addicted to Oil: Part Two," NPR - WBUR - The Connection, (26 April 2005).
      Ladies and Gentlemen the end of oil is upon us...or is it? The answer depends on who you ask. Energy analysts, geologists, oil executives and politicians all have a different theory.
    In America, most of the oil is used for transportation. Many drivers are cringing over prices at the pump; prices that range from $2.24 a gallon up to as high as $2.65.
    Everyone is trying to figure out why prices are high and what is ahead for next year and beyond. That is where the issue of the oil supply is key, because if the world is really running out, then we might as well expect the price to keep on climbing.
    There is a lot more to the story, and we try to get to the bottom of the barrel in our ongoing series "Addicted to Oil."
 
  "Addicted to Oil: Part Three," NPR - WBUR - The Connection, (27 April 2005).
      They are the cars that are marked to transform the sound and the smell of America's roads. From hybrids to fuel cells, drivers are turning their attention to alternative fuel vehicles. The wait for a Toyota Prius, the hottest selling hybrid, is several months. Don't even ask about the wait for the fuel cell car. It could be 10 or 20 years. But many say it is worth waiting for any car that gets 55 miles to the gallon.
    In today's world of climbing gas prices, cars that aren't as sexy or powerful as the SUV are starting to make more sense.
    Later today, President Bush is expected to ask lawmakers for billions more in tax breaks for these alternative fuel vehicles. Is this the road to the future? U.S. car makers and energy companies are saying, maybe, and still hedging their bets. The technology of driving in our ongoing series Addicted to Oil.
 
  "Addicted to Oil: Part Four," NPR - WBUR - The Connection, (28 April 2005).
      An oil industry report earlier this month predicted that prices could climb to $100 a barrel. At the same time, the House of Representatives has passed a bill with countless provisions for increasing production of fossil fuel. There is not much there to discourage consumption.
    Today we conclude our series "Addicted to Oil" with a hard look at the psyche of the American consumer and why it is, given all that we know about the environmental, political and biological havoc caused by oil, we continue to pump and pump and pump.
    Some say that its the American affection for its cowboy on the frontier past that's blinding it to today's call for global responsibility. Can a nation that defines freedom as autonomy and success as being bigger than your neighbor ever learn to stop driving alone and become a conservation nation?


What about the power of investments in a post-industrial economy? where governments have failed to regulate, can this movement bring about reform in the market place?



"Ethical Investing " NPR - WBUR - The Connection, (3 May 2005).
 

You won't find "booze, butts or bets" in Amy Domini's $1.5 billion Social Equity Fund. In the world of finance, she is known as a pioneer who came up with the idea for socially responsible investing decades ago.

Unlike most mutual funds that base their holdings on the earnings of a company, rather than the ethics, Domini will not invest in companies that don't protect the environment or respect their workers.

Making those choices isn't easy. You won't find WalMart or General Electric in her portfolio but you will see McDonalds, Merck and JP Morgan Chase. Changing their ways, she says, is part of the game. While her fund is not in the list of top-performers, Domini says it's doing very well -- mixing morals and money.

 

Business Week
2005
"A House That Costs Nothing to Run," Business Week, (20 September 2005).
 

Meet the Moomaws. Their goal is to build a retirement home in New England that will produce as much electricity as it consumes

Ask the average person to describe their dream retirement home, and what will you hear? Visions of high ceilings, gourmet kitchens, an expansive yard, maybe even a Jacuzzi. Bill and Margot Moomaw, a couple from Massachusetts, have a totally different kind of dream: They want a retirement home so efficient that it actually produces as much electricity as it consumes.

Now, three-or-so years away from retirement, Bill, a 67-year-old professor of international environmental policy at Tufts University, and his wife, 64, are about to break ground on a painstakingly planned low-energy dream home in Williamstown, in Western Massachusetts (see "The Moomaw's Model Home"). While the house will employ a lot of special technology, ranging from solar panels to a geothermal heat pump, the first rule is that their future residence house must look and feel "normal."


** Return to Syllabus **